| 1st Team |
| 2010 |
Steven Tilmon |
Midfield |
| 2010 |
Trey Gordon |
Midfield/Face Off |
| 2009 |
Ben Nielsen |
Attack |
| |
Kory Lutes |
Midfield |
| |
Steven Tilmon |
Midfield |
| |
Trey Gordon |
Face Off |
| |
Sam Studstill |
Defense |
| 2008 |
Blake Studstill |
Defense |
| |
Kory Lutes |
Midfield |
| 2007 |
Blake Studstill |
Defense |
| 2nd Team |
| 2010 |
Jake Rooney |
Attack |
| 2009 |
Clarke Johnson |
Goalie |
| |
Kyle Plaugher |
Attack |
| 2008 |
Ben Nielsen |
Attack |
| 2007 |
Kory Lutes |
Midfield |
| Honorable Mention |
| 2008 |
Steven Tilmon |
Midfield |
| |
Clarke Johnson |
Goalie |
|
|
| 1st Team |
| 2009 |
Kristina Coppolino |
Attack |
| |
Christy Turner |
Midfield |
| 2nd Team |
| 2009 |
Jessica Rooney |
Attack |
| |
Alyssa Savitz |
Defense |
|
